Did you ever hear the old saying that if you sit long enough in a sidewalk café in Paris, eventually everyone you've ever met will pass by? I wonder if there's an equivalent for operatic longings, because I can't believe I finally had a chance, thanks to San Francisco Opera's fall season, to experience Thea Musgrave's Mary, Queen of Scots, which I have wanted to hear since I first read about it when it was new, back in 1977, even though I didn't listen to much opera then. The subject matter was immediately appealing to somebody who was already obsessed with Shakespeare & had been riveted by Keith Mitchell as Henry VIII & Glenda Jackson as Queen Elizabeth I on Masterpiece Theater. I had also read Antonia Fraser's biography of the Scottish Queen. Having now seen the opera, I can only say I'm a bit surprised it took this long for it to come around, as it is an excellent work. And this production by & large did it justice.
Like Wagner & Cole Porter, Musgrave wrote the words she set to music, & she did an outstanding job laying out, clarifying, & dramatizing this complicated & twisted story of family, religious, & political struggles, a story made all the more complicated because families, religions, & politics were all bound together inseparably in that world. As mentioned above I had read the Fraser biography of the Queen, but so long ago that I retained mostly some names & some relatively vague impressions, but the stakes in this opera are high & clear without prepping beforehand. Musgrave based her libretto on a play by Amalia Elguera, who undoubtedly deserves some of the credit, but it was ultimately Musgrave who decided what to include & how to present it in her opera. Elguera's play is titled Moray, after James, Earl of Moray, the Queen's half-brother, so I'm inferring the play's focus was a bit different from the oepra's, but I haven't read the play so I don't know for sure.
The opera opens when Mary has returned from Catholic France to Scotland, to claim the throne of a country she barely knows. The afore-mentioned James, Earl of Moray, has turned Protestant but seems supportive of his sister, though one senses that's mostly because he thinks he can control her. There also seem to be quasi-incestuous longings for his attractive stepsister wrapped up in his ambition. Also in play are the Earl of Bothwell, a powerful military leader; the increasingly unhinged Lord Darnley, whom the Queen disastrously marries; & David Riccio, an aesthetic & handsome young friend from exotic Italy who falls victim to deadly court & romantic intrigues. There are also various women of the court & a Catholic Cardinal keeping a cold assessor's eye on the swirling situation. The populace also appears, in the form of a chorus, & there's Mary herself, glamorous & appealing, but also young, headstrong (how could she be otherwise, raised to believe that she has been placed in her position by God's will?), & on the naive side. There's a lot going on here, clearly (& the clearness is thanks to Musgrave's skill).
There are some attempts in the program book to position Mary as an astute leader, but I don't find them all that convincing. But then it would take a political genius, someone like Mary's cousin Elizabeth I of England, who ultimately cut off her potentially dangerous cousin's head, to harness the snarling tigers of this society convulsed by religious, dynastic, & territorial battles. Mary's execution at the order of a cousin she never met takes place long after the events of this opera, which climaxes when she flees the untenable Scottish situation for what she hopes is the refuge of England. (Mary never saw her son, the future James VI of Scotland & James I of England, successor to Elizabeth, after his infancy; for all the importance of bloodlines & dynasties here, there are quite a few close relatives who never actually meet each other in the flesh.) The final act on stage is a swift & surprising one, which I will leave undescribed, but it's quite the coup de théâtre. In Musgrave's telling this all makes quite a gripping tale, even for those familiar with the story, or the outline of the story.
Musgrave makes fruitful use of the varied cultural strands that exist often uneasily side by side in early modern Scotland. There are the sturdy folk sounds of Scotland itself, but also the sophisticated art of France, where Mary has spent most of her life, & the playful eroticism of Italy, a country which must have seemed to the Scots & Brits of the time the way Manhattan seemed to 1930s rural Americans. There is a punchy scene in which the various factions use their different musics against each other, a tour de force for the composer. I hesitate to describe the sound world of this opera as "Brittenesque" because that makes it sound derivative, so please consider the term more of a signpost pointing you in roughly the right direction. I found the music consistent enticing & attractive, enough so that I plan to look for a recording. Clelio Cafiero did a beautiful job leading the orchestra.
As mentioned I would love to see this opera again, though perhaps in a different staging. This one, directed & designed by Stewart Laing for the English National Opera, had some good points, but it used a single set, a haphazard-looking assemblage of open tents behind a flimsy fence that ran the length of the stage, & it all looked like something you might toss up quickly in the backyard for a party. And the costumes were insistently, even relentlessly, contemporary (contemporary with us, not Mary). The overwhelming sense was of costs being shaved & corners being cut, though the director did have a legitimate & even powerful point to make about the setting: he wanted the action seen as a deadly earnest power struggle, not some sort of heritage costume pageant.
It's a fair point. But it's also a bit misleading to present this story as the equivalent of a current-day political or dynastic power struggle. For us, the royal family, any royal family, is (choose one of the following): an annoying set of parasites, an amusing on-going soap opera, or a fun bit of heritage cosplay: in any case, a political anachronism, whether adored or despised or viewed with basically benign indifference. But the people in this story all truly believed in the divine right of rulers. And while religion is not irrelevant these days, it is also not essential as it was then, & we have no need to fear if a Catholic ruler takes over & we're Protestants or vice versa. Pretending that the situation portrayed here could be happening now obscures probably the two most significant drivers pressing the action forward: it very much matters who is the ruler, & it matters what religion that ruler follows.
Even if you're going with the contemporary costuming, they could have done more to highlight the differences among the factions: the military types could have been in fatigues, the aristocrats, particularly those who had lived abroad (meaning, in continental Europe) could have been more stylishly dressed, the Queen could have been more glam. This was a world acutely aware of the power of image (even now, centuries later, people are still writing studies of the way Elizabeth I formed & manipulated her image as an exercise in power). There are reasons iconography is a thing. All that aside, there's also something to be said for the sheer pleasure of fancy costumes; one of the attractions of opera, that impure art, is the visual splendor of the setting, in addition to the lyric & dramatic qualities of the work.
The cast was extremely compelling. There were a high number of Adler Fellows in the cast – Olivier Zerouali, Sadie Cheslak, Sofia Gotch Matry Hoskins, Alexa Frankian – & they all did themselves proud, particularly Thomas Kinch as a wild boar of an Earl of Bothwell. Hadleigh Adams was an elegant David Riccio, & Thomas Mole a complex Moray, whose ambiguous behavior could be viewed as deceptive or supportive or far-sighted (but in whose favor?), a man whose ultimate game is known only to himself. The Queen of them all, giving a dazzling display of authority & caprice, a woman both powerful & a pawn, was Heidi Stober in the title role, singing with gorgeous tone & total conviction through the many shades of Mary's dramatic life. Stober has given many outstanding performances here, but this was surely one of the greatest & most memorable. I hope she gets another chance to perform this significant work, & soon.
No comments:
Post a Comment