15 November 2026

San Francisco Opera: Le Nozze di Figaro

Years ago someone asked me: if you could pick only one opera, which would it be? After my usual protest that this is a particularly silly & pointless game (you don't actually have to choose! listen to them all! embrace diversity! accept abundance!), I said I had to have two: Tristan und Isolde & Le Nozze di Figaro, because with those two you have everything: one epic & mythic, the other rooted in a very particular time & place; one an almost action-free examination of the interior life of two people, the other a crowded, buzzing social panorama, full of plot devices; one essentially tragic, the other essentially comic; one exploring sex as a philosophy & a gateway to ecstasy & death, the other about sex, & the attempts to control it, or subvert those controls, that form our social institutions . . .  you get the idea. Both are long, both are filled with indelible music, both require high artistry to bring off, & while Tristan arguably is designed so that no performance can ever be sufficient & enough, Nozze is, perhaps, almost equally impossible to bring off, requiring artistry at the highest levels of sensitivity & skill. I have seen some performances that, despite some faults, I loved, & others that, despite some virtues, I loathed. The latest San Francisco Opera production, a revival of the 2019 Michael Cavanaugh production as restaged & revised by Shawna Lucey, wasn't one I loved, nor did I loathe it. This is, needless to say but I'll say it, an imperfect world.

For me the problems started with conductor Sebastian Weigle. This score, is of course, one of the most splendiferous ever written; the cairn raised in tribute to it needs no pebbles from me. But at the performance I attended (the second in the run), I felt that everything proceeded, for the performance's nearly four-hour run time (that's even with the fairly standard cuts of the Act 4 arias for Marcellina & Basilio), at the same pace & the same volume; nothing was done to point or magnify the action; even at moments when you want the music to melt in fluid & tender melancholy (in particular, the Countess's Dove sono & her letter duet with Susanna), the orchestra churned along in an almost oom-pah-pah style, undercutting the fine & sensitive singing from Olivia Smith as the Countess & Slávka Zámečníková as Susanna. I found it a bit exhausting. The most gorgeous & elegant steamroller in the world is still a steamroller.

The production itself edged towards the incoherent. I did not see this staging when it was new, probably for the usual reasons (time & money), but I also had decided, after seeing too many productions in which the program book praised Mozart's warm, loving, humanistic music only to have the directors & performers trotting out overdone caricatures & stale vaudeville routines, that I should maybe give the work & myself a bit of a break. So I'm not sure exactly how much has been changed for this revival. My recollection from what I read about the first performance is that it's set in the United States shortly after the Revolution, in an under-construction house that is obviously based on Monticello, & the servant characters (particularly Figaro & Susanna) were played by Black performers, while the aristocrats were White. This is an interesting idea; one problem with any production of Nozze that is set away from its original time & place is that the droit du Seigneur angle doesn't really transfer, but by setting the work in Monticello, with the notorious miasma of President Jefferson's relationship (or, if you prefer, "relationship") with his enslaved woman Sally Hemings hanging over everything, the antiquated right (or assumption) is given an urgent & vital meaning. That whole racial angle was dropped in this production, so, as usual, many of the pressing issues were rendered anodyne through distance: the early United States has some resonance with 18th-century Seville, but maybe not enough to make the relocation really useful or thought-provoking. The Americana elements always came as a surprise to me, & I had to keep reminding myself that the setting had been changed (the costumes were period & would have served for Spain as well as Virginia).

Throughout the staging, themes & suggestions make an appearance & then drop out of sight. It's like one of those buildings that incorporate chunks of a more conceptually ornate original structure to fill out a blanker modern facade. There are a couple of scenes in which extraneous servants (kitchen workers, for example) appear to be eavesdropping but nothing really develops the temporarily suggested atmosphere of surveillance & gossiping & most of that crowd of servants are not seen again. At the end of Act 2, while the Count (Thomas Mole) & his allies are awaiting the arrival of Marcellina & Co to press her marriage claim against Figaro, they indulge in a little dance routine, complete with jazz hands; it's an amusing moment of stylization, but it comes from nowhere & nothing like it recurs. The end of Act 1, when Figaro tells hapless & horny Cherubino about the glories of military life that await him, is weirdly unsettling in this staging. Cherubino is of course a trousers role; this particular Cherubino, as sung by Simone McIntosh, is quite diminutive & looks about 10 years old, & also looks very much on the girly side, with his golden Mary Pickford ringlets & his elegant rose-pink velvet suit. A life in the army seems extremely improbable. This tiny figure is, while Figaro sings, surrounded by looming "peasants", grinning in a very unsavory, creepy way. I'm doubtful the gay-bashing / pedophiliac overtones were intended (fi they were, it's another element that is presented & then dropped without development). Then suddenly the crowd dissolves into a tableau re-creating Washington Crossing the Delaware – someone in the crowd conveniently happens to have an appropriate flag to hand – & we are spared any traumatizing developments.

There was some vulgar cartoon violence that was intentional: when Susanna sees Figaro embracing his newly discovered mother, Marcellina, & thinks he's going to marry the older woman after all, she usually gives him a slap or two. This time, she punched (or possibly kicked, I don't remember) him in the crotch so forcefully that he collapsed in pain, & then, once he was down, she started kicking him. In Act 4, when he's teasing her by pretending to make love to the Countess, the usual slap or two is replaced with a vigorous pummeling. There are some social & theatrical conventions of Mozart's time that don't translate well to ours, & masters beating servants for laughs is one of them, & though that is not technically the situation here, the objection still applies – or so I would have thought. I find it – I'll go with interesting – that in a period of what I had assumed was heightened sensitivity to abusive relationships, those involved in this production chose – twice – to ratchet up the violence. (Figaro is, of course, in both instances innocent of what Susanna is assuming, not that I think it makes much difference when it comes to this level of abuse.)

I was probably naive to think that we are in fact in a time of heightened sensitivity; usually what happens is that people merely rearrange their unreasoning prejudices in more socially pleasing forms. But setting aside the mockery of & social stigma towards men who are abused by their partners, these overdone attacks are a dramatic & psychological mistake. Susanna has obviously been pushed to an extreme, but you need to feel she is basically loving & kind. Figaro talks big, but she is the calm-headed one who can really see & manipulate a situation. Look at the couples at the end of the play: the Count & Countess are reconciled, but you don't need to know the third play in Beaumarchais's trilogy to see that all will not be smooth sailing there. Bartolo & Marcellina have made it legal, but you don't feel much will actually otherwise change in their grumpy but mostly familiar & comfortable-enough domesticity. You really want & need to feel that Figaro & Susanna are going to have a mutually loving & supportive partnership. You should not wish that some kind friend would urge him to set aside masculine pride & think very carefully about committing himself to someone who will fly off the handle & cause him serious physical harm at her slightest suspicion.

That miscalculation was perhaps more surprising in that this production handled some other things very well. In particular, the relationship between the Countess & Cherubino, which is often grotesquely overdone (rendering her loving protestations of innocence hypocritical & ridiculous) is handled lightly & appropriately. This really is a major point in this production's favor. I also liked the subtle way the Count was handled in the finale: he has bowed to necessity & as graciously as possible asked the Countess for her forgiveness, which she freely gives, but as the final chorus rejoices, he is a bit off to the side, a bit withdrawn, suggesting (as noted above) that this reconciliation is not going to last all that long. I appreciated the thoughtfulness of that moment all the more in that most of the other crowd scenes were, I thought, flaccidly staged: when Cherubino is unmasked as one of the servant girls in disguise, & when the various people hiding in the garden in Act 4 are pulled out from the bushes, I knew what was happening mostly because I knew what was supposed to be happening.

The cast was generally good. As mentioned earlier, I found the Countess & Susanna particularly strong (which is another reason it was a shame to have Susanna unleash crude & excessive physical violence on someone she supposedly loves). I liked the Count quite a lot; this is probably the most unsympathetic role in the play, at least for a 21st-century audience, but Mole brought as much dignity & gravitas to the part he could. (When he overhears Susanna, who he thought had just agreed to an assignation with him, giggling with Figaro, & he asks himself "is this a plot?" a man near me loudly announced, "Yes, it is!" Thank you sir, & I wonder how opera audiences ever got the reputation for being "sophisticated".)  Peter Kellner as Figaro is quite a lively fellow. He seemed to caper a lot. Alek Shrader does not overdo the gossipy bitchy side of Basilio & is the more convincing & amusing for it. Catherine Cook as Marcellina & Maurizio Muraro as Bartolo are old pros at their roles, & the evident wear in their voices is suitable for their characters.

No comments: