10 November 2006

my nights were sour. . . .

Ah, Tristan, the opera that ruined my life. . . . (“Do you want to go out for coffee?” “Well . . . is this going to end in an ecstatic love-death that will annihilate space and time? Because otherwise, I kinda have some stuff I need to get done. . . . those dishes aren’t going to wash themselves. . . .”). If I were limited to two operas, I think I would take Tristan und Isolde and Le Nozze di Figaro: between them you pretty much have the universe, with the ecstasy and sorrow of the former’s inward-looking lovers balanced by the latter’s earthy joys amid a complex, shifting social structure. I wonder if Tristan isn’t one of those works like King Lear that is almost too mighty for people to act out on stage, leaving every performance both deeply moving and inadequate.

Bayreuth had a wonderful cast for Tristan; it was everything else that came up short. Beforehand I was hearing raves about Nina Stemme’s Isolde, and she did have amazing power but, I felt, started to run out of gas during the liebestod, which is when you least want that to happen. The one who really impressed me was Robert Dean Smith, who sang a Tristan of brave sweetness and anguish. Our Kurwenal, John Wegner, was much steadier than the man who did the broadcast performance (that’s the paradox of opera reviewing – even if the performers had been the same, you’d get a different performance from evening to evening, and sometimes from act to act).

The production was baffling. The pictures that I saw beforehand made me think it would have a contemporary setting, which could be an interesting way of examining the mythic and heroic within the everyday. But the actual staging starts out looking like a 1930s luxury liner, as if everyone is going to break into “Anything Goes” and start tapdancing; the Cole Porter connotations have a way of reducing gestures that should be majestic to the Margaret-Dumontish. But when V (who has a keener fashion awareness than I do) saw pictures of the costumes she asked why it was set in the 1960s. I responded that I would have guessed the 1970s, based on the fake wood paneling and mustard yellow décor of the finale. Updating a work to contemporary times is one thing, but I'm not sure updating something to forty years ago has much point.

The costume designer certainly didn’t do anyone in the cast any favors. I had seen Stemme in SF Opera’s Flying Dutchman, and knew she could look better, but it wasn’t until Robert Dean Smith stepped into Siegmund’s furs for Act II of Walkure that I realized he could look like a big guy rather than an inflated boy, and Kwangchul Youn’s sensitively sung and moving King Mark looked distractingly like Kim Jong Il.

Tristan is like other operas turned inside out; instead of reflective moments amid action it has moments of action amid hours of soliloquy. This can certainly lead to staging problems, but the Bayreuth production dealt with most of them by simply having people stand facing the wood paneling when they weren’t singing, as if they were in time-out. This is not staging but surrender. The wounding of Tristan, which he clearly did to himself, was effective, but everything else just didn’t happen, so that you didn't get a sense of the bustle and pointless violence of the outside world breaking in on the two lovers.

Speaking of bustle and pointlessness intruding on one’s inner universe. . . this was the night I had to accept that Bayreuth audiences are really not much better than any others, rumors to the contrary. Why did the man behind me need to reach into his rustly crinkly plastic bag during all the quiet moments? Another mystery of opera-going. . . .

1 comment:

God entered into my body, like a body. my perfect size. this is holy ghost baptism. acts 2:38 in the bible said...

the grim reaper pointing at duncan rouleau and his family, like jonah weiland, michael hull, Reverend S. M. Scott, Rebekah bekah girl, Lee Grady, James C. Moberg, Gabriel Leonard, Roy Sauzek, Ron King , Dan Jessen, Ben Arment, nolan bobbitt, Robby mac, mary nella mclaughlin, ann marie, Gerry Mc Daniel, dave wilson, todd callender, Matthew Littleton, Amos R. Albright, Sean von Tagen, Laurie Hirata, Barbara O'Brien, John Strong, Chris Forbes, Keith Page, Kathryn Aragon, Paul R. Mitchell, Mike Oppenheimer, Daniel Brown, Steve Stephens, Ronald V. Duncan, Carroll Marr, Mike Slaughter, Donald W. Ebelt, Jr, Rich DuBose, andy jayne, Jayne, President Joseph Castleberry, jim null from medsend, Andy, Jayne, Ken Himes, D.Min., CKYT Radio 13's sistermoonshine13, sistermoonshine13@hotmail.com, Sam Huddleston, Tim Colovos, Ken Godevenos, renee delorenzo, sistermoonshine13, Kurt McClung, sabrina mckenzie, Paula M. Cavu, Rizza Legaspi, James Mills, Carl Schenck, BARB BALLARD, Mike Bickle, Yvonne Platts, john wright, Rick Frye, Paul and Agnès Sanders, Lynda Freeman, Dora Dueck, Rev. Dr. John H. Thompson, Sr, John Theis, Ali Klees, Duane Ray, Terry Pratchett, Darlene Zschech, Lou Engle, Nadia Dronova, valoria cheek, RevTripp, Rev Tripp, Gifts from God Ministries, Sue Shaw, margaret marcuson, Ronnie Floyd, Woodley, Matt ; Woodley, Julie, Eddy Hall, Jennifer Gale, Thomas Reddinger, Ms. Garnet, Ginny Olson, Diane Elliot, Mike Work, Howard Culbertson, Senyum Sayang, Dana Reardon, Robert Tulip, Karl Kobrock, dan burrell, Mark Inouye, Bill Donahue, Terry Bates, Kathy Lefler, Jason Boyett , Pinto, Francisco's pastor bryan article, BEN BINGER, Carl Nash, Deb Wilkins, John Godson, Misja Pielgrzym, Kosciol Bozy w Chrystusie, Jim Coons, Chris Beach, ken hammonds, John Bjorge, shaun groves, Jack Hammans, marynella mclaughlin, Curt Swindoll, CEO, brian m. Albrecht, Marilyn Strauss, Bethany Yeo, Wayne Jacobsen, John Klees and Micki Cabaniss, David W. Henderson, Tim and Daphne Stapleton, shawn brown, nelson osamu hayashida, Scottie May, Dayton, Ed, ed dayton, Dominic & Nomi Sola's Michelle M. , Larry Crabb, Childress, Jeffrey, Craig Rucin, Michelle M, Wilson L. Deaton, David Mackin, Danny Stone, Fred Smith, President, The Gathering, Dr. Kenneth Boa, Mark Peterson, Bonnie Brann, frank rosensterndoug , Jay & Linda Threadgill, small, ismail kadare, janetmck, arron shutt, george doran, elizabeth shea, Ken Kelly, andy shaw, tom beland, kenley darling, quinling harlequin, Fred Knoll, Derek Lynas, david shapiro, Lynsae Harkins, cecil pennyton, joe lalich, dave karlotski, daugan, Amanda at Mama sings: Leaving Egypt, Steve F., justin daniels davis, john mark pool, Shawn brown, Kermit Netteburg, Eugene Oh, tim baker, Josh McDowell, Erik A. Olson, Don Rose, YWAM Latvia, jose alvarez, dee finney, antonia vladimirova, Jay Ashcraft , Leroy Freeman, carla educar, katie bazor, Carl Creasman, andrew deal, Ron Klabunde, Ambrose Roasa, Peter Fitchamanda dee, Mitch Anderson, Tim Schmoyer, jeff dee, reverend jeremy taylor, d.min, christina marie sanford, jean patrick charrey got Fazile Zahir got Zespó³ Doradców Gospodarczych, “TOR”, Spó³ka, greg titus, BaldySlaphead, Max Lopez, Evan McBroom, mike kenney, Douglas L. Fagerstrom, Rick Frye, brian, bill of the massive bri, Bruce Ryskamp, lawrence forman, micheru mathys, dana tillusz, George Tramountanas, John Lawry, John Jaszcz, and Randy Williams, JK Rowling, Nakul Chander, Wally Schmidt, Kiel Nunn, nick field, Heuva, michael doran, Alexander McConnell, William Revell Moody, Arthur Percy Fitt, erick Fazile Zahir, Pastor Erick Waukegan, IL
youth ministry liaison for the North Central Conference of the Free Methodist, Greg Bayaca and The Rev. Gerry Engnan, don and Linden Petrin, Bert McCumsey, Paul Meier, Chris Nelson, Alicia, Sung Hyun Um, John H. Thompson, Trond Hundstuen, Jim Case, Karen L. Schmidt, Andrey Stepanyuk , Dan Seidman, Tim Howey , Greg & Sherry, Dr. R. Mark Beadle, blaine motsinger, Jerry Frear, Konstantin Ternianov, janet mcknight, Laurie Behncke, Heuva, Zespó³ Doradców Gospodarczych, “TOR”, Spóka, Brad Gee, Senior Pastor,
Fazile Zahir richard starkings, joe kelly, mike hull, cesar gonzalez, Hugh T. Blevins, Jr., daniel kaps, SCHRAMM, Richard, Dean Galvin, Lusine Safaryan, diana hughey, Thom S. Rainer, Ronald L Hawkins, wendi hammond, helen calder, Bob McQueary, Richard E. Lauersdorf, brian hirt, bill hamon Zespó³ Doradców Gospodarczych, “TOR”, Spó³ka, Dann Pantoja, robert winer, paul dixon, rohn price, diana hughey, Mhada Oshiwara, Andheri West, dan kaps, Nicholson, Roy, john m. bailey, Richard L. Reising, phil at vibrance in ministry, Julie Lautt, Henry Doorn, Jack Ellis, Gordon Miller, dave at faf@ag.org, Jay Mooney, Pastor Ellen, Michael Cork, John Yates, Richard F. Myers, Willam Murray, larry clow, Darrell G. Young, david reagan, Paul Sang, Valoria L. Cheek, thom s. rainer, eric geiger, Sabrina McKenzie Ministries, Larry Frank, renewla, Alex Choi
, rex frieze, kiddos galore, Alissa Bertsch, Walt Mueller, Jay Mooney, Diamond Management Consultants dave moon, Chandigarh Express, Pete Widdop, Annette LaPlaca, Delbert Enns, Rev. Dr. John H. Thompson, Sr, President, scott morton, John Drage, Pastor Bill Dornbush, Duane Ray, Ali Klees, Lawrence McCorkle Gill’s family, CP-TEL, Jason Boyett, Stephen Felts, Kathy Lefler,Dr. James W. Dyer, Jr., Kathy Schaeffer, Joyce Strong, Alan Fox, John Wray, Matt Jones, John Engels, kobe holler, Jeremy Camp, Chris Bush, ARMEN BERJIKLY like Sabrina McKenzie, Frank Braun, Julia A. Spohrer, rick long, Shusaiyuan Biz, David Bearden, Al Jourgensen, Rick Warren, Stefanie Farrone, Len Kageler, Arthur Cherrie, R. Paul Stevens, Charles R. Shumate, Michael & Karen McDonald, Pat Verbal, Dr. mike Murdock, Phillip Butler, Ross Slaughter , Howard Culbertson, James L. Benedict, Michael Bartley, Carole Louise Sawatzky is lost, cut off saith God, John Freeman, Ed Young, Rick Cruse, Dr. Steve Stephens, Elizabeth Cullen, Joyce Strong, Annette LaPlaca, dr. kara powell, Matt Woodley and Julie Woodley, Barry St. Clair, Chad Zaucha, Rick Warren, B.A. Cooley, Susan Riddle, Micah Andrews, scottie may, beth posterski, catherine stonehouse, linda cannell, Brian Kluth, Doug Diehnelt, Jennifer Gale, Paul McDonald, Eric Brass, JEANIE STANLEY, Mr. William Stevens, Safiyah Marshay, India Arie, jeanie r. stanley,
Luke Brouillette, Doug Haugen and Andrew Bosch, Rev. Dr. M. Hadwin Fischer, Matthew Nowlin, howard culbertson, Paula M. Cavu and Dr Gavin Porter PhD, dr. sheikh muszaphar and dr. faiz Dann Pantoja, Lee Dodd, brandon teer, Hurckman, Tom R. Harper, amerintia human, Lee Gugliotto, Ph.D., David Neal, brittany hill, Pastor Billy Joe Daugherty, lemar mast, Rev. Stephen Reed, Steve Angello, Terry & Donna Keith, Heber E. Rast Jr., matt cario, Belinda Wright, Henri Nouwen, RANDALL K. KNUTSON, carmen joyce, Sr. Pastor Don Underwood, Ernestine Youngs, Dr. Rodney A. Harrison, Chris Alford, bruce marchiano, Julia A. Spohrer, Brian Kluth, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Rev. José Zito Oliveira and Mrs. Zilta Rocha de Carvalho Oliveira Art Beals, Alisha Beverly, reiki music, lindsay greer, luke greer, Dennis Edwards, Chris Forbes, Keith Page, ginny olson, diana elliot, and mike work, dave wilson, HB London and Neil B. Wiseman, Elizabeth House, josh hunt, Dennis Klussman, Wszelkie prawa zastrzeżone, Jimmy Williams, Michael Ward, sunnysnet, sunnysweb, Dr. R. Mark Beadle of SEVENSTAR ACADEMY, michele rickett, sisters in service, Mike and Kerry Clarensau, VERLIN BYERS, glenn gerdes, wayne muirhead, ted Engstrom, krista petty, Tim Boyd, Vic Kennett, Sr. M. Dolorosa, R. Kent Hughes, Richard Woughter, SeLahGirl, Daniel Brown, Eddy Hall, Gary & Carrie Espeseth, Mark Warnock, Deborah F. Jenks, sue mickey, Clifton Eshbach and Pastor Conrad B., mn church planting, Ruth Ann, kobe aka skreetpreacha, Jenny Duff, COREY, WAYNE, DAN, Jeri Rose, Dr. Stephen J. Carter, Rob Martini, Pastor Mark Burch, Dwyndl, Lori, Noah & Bayley Nelms, Steve Roesch, Nicholas Wolterstorff, The Rev. LeRoy L. Carlson, jared cramer, Paul and Agnès Sanders, Dave & Dawn Bovenmyer, Dennis Klussman, tim chan, Kimberley Ward, Kip Gilts, Sheila Swafford, Jane Fitzjerrell, Nilson Kibbey, kimberly giarrusso, Aleathea Dupree, Joseph Boerman, Bob Cramer, Denise Knight, Rich Stone, RICK KINDSCHI, ron c. scott noble, keith johnson, these are all duncan rouleaus children, he wrote a book, with the stolen name ministry of dreams, they, most, posted his article, or stole, the name ministry of dreams to make prophet fall, all release ruint, this is duncan rouleaus family, they want Gods servant to fall,