Last night at Herbst Theater I heard the annual Adler Fellows Concert, presented as usual under the somewhat alarming & admonitory rubric The Future Is Now. It was quite an enjoyable evening, featuring many striking & even luxurious voices.
There were no surtitles, which surprised me a bit, as they have become so standard in opera houses, but this was an old-school show, of the type few of us remember now, with only a short summary in the program to guide us through the aria. Or the duet, as there were some of those; there were no larger ensembles. And we couldn't count on familiarity, as some of the selections were from rarities. There were no composers earlier than Donizetti, & none later than Menotti. The latter was the only number in English. I always wonder how they select & assign the musical pieces. Suitability to the performer at this stage in his/her/their career, balancing the overall program, offering variety & a show of skills, & things that the Adlers will at least possibly be asked to sing at some point. . . though these days an opera house is just as likely to be looking for singers who can handle Rodgers & Hammerstein or Sondheim rather than Cilea – though I'm delighted to have a backwards glance at the latter's work. Maybe they just pull arias out of a hat. These are the mysteries of how the musical sausage is made.
Our conductor for the evening, leading the San Francisco Opera Orchestra, was Sebastian Weigle, who has been leading the band in the big house in the current revival of Nozze di Figaro. I liked him much better last night than I did in the Mozart; I found him more responsive to the singers: you could not only see it, in the way he frequently turned his head to check on them (the singers were at the front of the stage; he was of course facing the orchestra behind them) but also hear it, in the livelier & more attentive support he gave them. The staging was by Elio Bucky. There was a bit of appropriate stage action but mostly things were very streamlined, simple & elegant. I assume he also helped the singers get into character, which they all did effectively. The men were stylish in evening wear & the women in elaborate & lovely gowns. Outside of a few opening remarks by San Francisco Opera Center leads Carrie-Ann Matheson (Artistic Director) & Markus Beam (General Manager), there was no talking from the stage, for which I was grateful: just a succession of arias, a string of pearls shown without comment. As I said, old school, & I was glad for that.
The appropriate opening number was baritone Gabriel Natal-Báez in a virile & vivid rendition of Tonio's Si può from Leoncavallo's Pagliacci, that classic reminder of the ambiguous space between theater, performer, & reality. That was followed by soprano Sofia Gotch in Ah, tardai troppo . . . O luce di quest'anima from Donizaetti's Linda di Chamounix, an aria in classic Italian opera style in which a lovelorn heroine gets to express various appropriate emotions over missing a rendezvous with her lover, though she does find, with ensuing rapture, the flowers he left behind. Such arias exist to display the soprano's gifts, & advantage was taken of the offered opportunities. That was followed by soprano Alexa Frankian & baritone Olivier Zerouali in an arresting & tense confrontation between the priestess Leïla & her lover's friend & rival, Nadir, from Bizet's The Pearl Fishers, an opera I find underrated. This isn't the most striking duet from that work but offers interest & tension enough to be an apt choice.
We then heard mezzo-soprano Sadie Cheslak in glamorous Acerba voluttà from Ciliea's Adriana Lecouvreur, a one-time favorite that occasionally makes an appearance in the living repertory. The first half closed with sopranos Mary Hoskins & Sofia Gotch as Arabella & her sister, the drag king Zdenka, from Richard Strauss's Arabella, a selection which made me intensely grateful for the lack of surtitles, as it's much easier to enjoy that misbegotten & misshapen opera if you have only the very cloudiest notion of what is going on. Gotch effectively conveyed Zdenka's complicated feelings towards the suitor she loves whom Arabella doesn't – you know what? I'm going to follow my own advice & not bother with the action of this particular opera. I will only note that Hoskins glowed with tender love & almost unworldly hope. I would sit through Arabella again to hear her in the role.
After the intermission, the performance resumed with Natal-Báez & tenor Thomas Kinch as Rodrigo & Carlo in a passionate rendition of the friendship duet from Verdi's epic Don Carlo (Italian version). That was followed by Frankian in Je dis que rien ne m'épouvante, Micaëla’s Act 3 aria in Carmen as she searches through the rough & unpoliced mountains for Don José, who has abandoned her. I was glad to see the singer present a tougher Micaëla than usual; she's often performed as a "theater" country girl – innocent, naive, weak – instead of a more realistic country girl, that is, made of sterner stuff, able to deal with the rougher facts of life. The contrast between her & that opera's titular woman is one between the steadfast & the mercurial, rather than the weak & the strong or, worst of all, the good & the evil.
Zerouali returned with a poignant rendition of an aria from Korngold's Die Tote Stadt: Pierrot's song Mein Sehnen, main Wähnen, which, like the Pagliacci aria that kicked things off, is a reflection on the reality of art versus the illusions of life. That was followed by the swirling ecstasies of Wagner's Siegmund (Kinch) & Sieglinde (Hoskins), as the recent strangers discover who they are, & what they are to each other from the first act of Die Walküre. Cheslak then returned with the sole selection in English, Afraid, Am I Afraid? from Menotti's The Medium. It was an effective short scene for a woman whose grim experiences of life have steeled her, she hopes, for an unexpected encounter with the supernatural. The evening closed with Gotch & Natal-Báez as Lucia & her brother Enrico in Donizetti's Lucia di Lammermoor. Once again it was maybe not the most obvious selection from that work, but none the worse for that; the two singers certainly gave intensely felt renditions, with sparkling high notes & thunderous lower ones used expressively as well as virtuosically.
All in all, a powerful display of some of the next generation of opera singers, carrying the art into the future (at least vocally; maybe they could have been given some material written after 1946). Several years ago I was discussing a sci fi book (I don't remember which, as I'm not a sci fi maven) with someone I didn't know well & I referred to this book, which is set, like most sci fi, in "the future" as dystopian; he gave me a look of pity & disappointment &, if I didn't mistake, slight disgust, & firmly said, "It's not a dystopian novel." I replied that I just assumed anything set in the future was, by definition, dystopian. That's just the way we live now. But even as the world collapses & burns around us, there's some consolation in hearing such young, beautiful, & hopeful voices carrying an old art into the murky future.




